• About
  • OSAR LIVE
  • Contact
Tuesday, February 7, 2023
OSAR
No Result
View All Result
  • Login
  • Caribbean
  • International
  • Caribbean
  • International
No Result
View All Result
OSAR
No Result
View All Result
Home Court

Dominica rebukes CCJ after it expressed “grave concerns” over 2019 general election

admin by admin
July 12, 2022
in Court
0
Dominica rebukes CCJ after it expressed “grave concerns” over 2019 general election
0
SHARES
6
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

The Government of Dominica has rebuked the Caribbean Court of Justice (CCJ) following a written judgement in a long-running election petition case, saying the regional body has departed from not commenting on matters it was not called upon to decide and for making gratuitous commentary on political affairs.

This after the CCJ made statements in the judgement in the case involving Glenroy Cuffy & Others v Melissa Skerrit, handed down on 5th July 2022.

READ ALSO

Trump sues CNN for defamation

Satanic Temple suing Indiana over state’s near-total abortion ban

That case involved ten election petitions alleging wrongdoing against a number public officers including the prime minister, electoral officers and police officers in the run up to the 2019 general elections held in Dominica.

In it’s judgement the CCJ commented about areas of “grave concerns” over how the elections were conducted, adding that future elections should not be held with such “taints.”

This did not go down well with the government of Dominica who said it was obliged to express disappointment on the matter, calling the comments “gratuitous” and saying that it hopes the CCJ takes appropriate steps to the clarify it and to avoid making commentaries on political affairs.

Background of the case

After the general elections of 2019, Glenroy Cuffy an Others (the petitioners) filed ten election petitions claiming that they were conducted in a manner contrary to established electoral laws and regulations of Dominica.

The respondents applied to have the petitions struck out, saying the petitions did not have sufficient details.

The trial judge agreed and struck out the petitions.

The petitioners then took the matter to the Court of Appeal, questioning the decision of the trial judge.

However, the respondents struck backing saying the Court of Appeal had no authority to hear it. They argued that the based on Sections 40 (6) and (7) of the Constitution of Dominica, appeals are made only against a final decision in law.

The Court of Appeal agreed with the respondents and declined to hear the appeal.

The petitioners then took the matter to the CCJ for special leave to appeal the Court of Appeal’s decision.

CCJ’s judgement

The matter was heard by the CCJ which refused the application for special leave and upheld the orders of the Court of Appeal.

It agreed with the Court of Appeal that the petitioners had no right to appeal the decision of the High Court judge to strike out their petitions.

However, the CCJ did not end there, noting there were areas of concerns over how the elections were conducted.

“There remain areas of grave concern about how the process of these elections was conducted. Future elections in Dominica ought not to proceed with these or similar taints,” it wrote in the judgement.

Reaction of Government of Dominica

In response the Government of Dominica stated that the comments by the CCJ had “caused unnecessary discord in Dominica” and they were “wrongly being viewed as an authoritative declaration by the CCJ that the Dominica Labour Party’s general election victory is questionable and have, unsurprisingly, fuelled public debate as to the legitimacy of the government.”

“In making those remarks, the CCJ departed from the sensible, time-honored practice of not commenting on matters it was not called upon to decide,” it said in a statement. “Furthermore, the so-called “taints” over which the Court expressed “grave concern” are nothing but bare allegations on which no findings have been made by any court of law. In the context of the tiny, divided society that is Dominica, it was reasonably foreseeable that such comments from the CCJ would have engulfed the society in dissension.”

The statement added, “The Government of Dominica hopes that given this serious and, no doubt, unintended state of affairs, the CCJ will take appropriate steps to clarify matters and avoid a repeat of this kind of gratuitous commentary on political affairs.”

Related Posts

Trump says he’s testifying Wednesday in NY investigation
Court

Trump sues CNN for defamation

October 4, 2022
Satanic Temple suing Indiana over state’s near-total abortion ban
Court

Satanic Temple suing Indiana over state’s near-total abortion ban

September 27, 2022
Pakistan court grants interim bail to former PM Imran Khan
Court

Pakistan court grants interim bail to former PM Imran Khan

August 25, 2022
Harbour Master crew fined for causing harm to Anderson Peters
Court

Harbour Master crew fined for causing harm to Anderson Peters

August 18, 2022
In Grenada crew members of Harbour Master plead guilty
Court

In Grenada crew members of Harbour Master plead guilty

August 16, 2022
Trump says he’s testifying Wednesday in NY investigation
Court

Trump says he’s testifying Wednesday in NY investigation

August 10, 2022
Next Post
Dominica relaxes Covid-19 restrictions effective April 4

St Lucia confirms first case of highly contagious COVID-19 variant

Please login to join discussion

POPULAR NEWS

Dominican shot execution-style in New York

Dominican shot execution-style in New York

March 31, 2022
“Why is my child?” – emotional mother of abducted child weeps

Statement by police on shooting death of Kian Alexander and search for Kernisha Etienne

June 19, 2022
Nightgown among items belonging to abducted child found in bushes

Nightgown among items belonging to abducted child found in bushes

June 9, 2022
Young Dominican journalist passes away

Young Dominican journalist passes away

May 25, 2022
Police in Dominica bring in trained dog and handler as search for abducted child continues

Police in Dominica bring in trained dog and handler as search for abducted child continues

June 9, 2022

EDITOR'S PICK

Dominica relaxes Covid-19 restrictions effective April 4

End of Covid pandemic ‘in sight’, says World Health Organization

September 15, 2022
Over 30,000 ePassports issued by Dominica since 2021

Over 30,000 ePassports issued by Dominica since 2021

July 7, 2022

OSAR’s Monday news package

May 25, 2022
Saint Lucia to remove service charge on price controlled goods

‘It hurt the Prime Minister’ – burglary at Pierre’s constituency office

August 18, 2022

About

OSAR Radio (Old Street Audacity Radio) is a 24/7 operation. Learn More.Learn More

Listen Live

Recent Posts

  • OSAR’s Monday news package
  • Suspected Chinese spy balloon shot down off South Carolina coast
  • Major earthquake in Turkey, Syria kills more than 1,300 people
  • OSAR’s Friday news package
  • Listen Live
  • About
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use

© 2022 Osar - Site by G & D Enterprises Inc.

No Result
View All Result
  • Caribbean
  • International

© 2022 Osar - Site by G & D Enterprises Inc.

Welcome Back!

Sign In with Facebook
Sign In with Google
Sign In with Linked In
OR

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In